instagram pinterest linkedin facebook twitter goodreads

Scholarly Work

When I was an undergraduate English major, there were no nineteenth-century American women writers. Oh, yes, there was Emily Dickinson, but my professor said we didn't have to pay much attention to her; she was "just a neurotic old maid flittering around her father's garden." When I read Emily Dickinson's poems, I LOVED them, but I was very young and kept it to myself. Then there was Louisa May Alcott, but she wrote for children, and Edith Wharton, but she was treated more as an early twentieth-century writer. I loved them, too, but not as much as Dickinson.


Years passed before I went to graduate school. Suddenly Emily Dickinson was an Important Poet, but there were few, if any, other nineteenth-century American women writers. It seemed very strange, as if Dickinson had been born directly from the head of Zeus, without a mother. Along with a couple of graduate school friends, I began to read musty volumes from the university library, books that hadn't been taken out since 1923. We read writers such as Susan Warner, Alice Cary, Maria Cummins, and we asked ourselves why these fascinating women writers had been so thoroughly "disappeared."

With the help of a few farseeing English professors at the University of Massachusetts, Martha Ackmann, Karen Dandurand and I founded what we initially thought would be a newsletter to inform other scholars of our findings. In so doing we came across other women scholars engaged in the same work of literary recovery, Nina Baym, Margo Culley, Judith Fetterley, Susan Harris, Elaine Showalter, Jane Tompkins, Sandra Zagarell. Our modest newsletter soon became LEGACY, a scholarly journal of American women writers that this year celebrates its twenty-fifth anniversary.


One problem, however: there were not enough musty old volumes to go around. Leslie Mitchner, a visionary editor from Rutgers University Press, approached Elaine Showalter, Judith Fetterly and me about editing a reprint series. This eventually became the Rutgers American Women Writers series, eighteen volumes of novels, short stories, essays, and poems that have transformed the college American literature curriculum, allowing the voices of a vibrant and accomplished group of women to be heard once again. I am delighted to have been a part of their resurrection. Now Emily Dickinson has sisters.